A Better Course

“thou hast councilled a better course than thou hast allowed”

A Better Course header image 1

Whose day?

November 29th, 2008 · 3 Comments



Nivea advert
Originally uploaded by Alexandra Mitchell


One of my most hated adverts of the moment is this one, for Nivea moisturiser. It is unreadably bland – what is actually going on? How does it relate to the tagline, “Look ready to face the day”?

There are some conclusions that we can draw about what’s going on here. There’s a guitar, and the only thing in the ad that isn’t flesh tone or product is blue, so it’s clearly the room of the man pictured. (Blue, in case you lost that memo in primary school, is the boy’s colour.) The man’s suit (and shirt with cufflinks) and tie places him in a position of some responsibility, probably client or customer facing, in a traditional industry. It seems safe to conclude that we are looking at a successful male, between his mid twenties and mid thirties, in his own bedroom.

The girl in the bed, however, complicates the picture. There are two quite separate conclusions that we can draw about the man – and by extension, the product that he uses – from the presence of a blonde woman in the bed.

In the first reading, the woman is his girlfriend, fianceĆ© or wife, and the product is the reason why she – along with the other symbols of worldly success – has come into his life. Having, thanks to Nivea moisturiser, been ready to face the day every day for the last decade, the man has a good job, a stable relationship, and a ground floor flat in a leafy suburb. The guitar, too, hints at a wide variety of expensive toys elsewhere in the flat. In this scenario, the moisturiser functions as The 7 Habits Of Highly Effective People.

In the second reading, the woman is essentially a stranger, returning to his home following a night out, probably a heavy night out, probably with co-workers. Thanks to Nivea moisturiser, the man need not show this signs of last night’s debauch on his face at work the next morning; he is as together as he always is, and ready to face the day. The guitar, in so many cases more fun to play than to listen to, points to a life lived entirely for the self. The moisturiser, far from the trusted friend and counsellor of the first reading, is The Picture of Dorian Gray.

It’s obvious that I’m not the target market for this product. But I don’t think the story an advert tells should be quite this obfuscated.

→ 3 CommentsCategories: advertising · marketing
Tags: , , ,

links for November 24th

November 24th, 2008 · Comments Off on links for November 24th

Comments Off on links for November 24thCategories: links
Tags:

links for November 19th

November 20th, 2008 · Comments Off on links for November 19th

Comments Off on links for November 19thCategories: links
Tags:

links for November 19th

November 19th, 2008 · Comments Off on links for November 19th

Comments Off on links for November 19thCategories: links
Tags:

links for November 18th

November 18th, 2008 · Comments Off on links for November 18th

Comments Off on links for November 18thCategories: links
Tags:

Money talk

November 18th, 2008 · Comments Off on Money talk

From Big Contrarian (specifically this post):

I know few people curtailing their spending habits. Quite the opposite. […] Anecdotes are of course useless, but the disconnect strikes me as something to think about.

The anecdotes here are, I think, interesting data points – are people spending less and consciously not talking about that? How long is the time laspse between spending less and talking about spending less? There’s already been an increase in adverts that don’t have any kind of message other than “This will save you money” – and I wonder if this is based on actual customers talking, and how much more nuanced these conversations actually are.

Comments Off on Money talkCategories: advertising · data
Tags:

links for November 9th

November 9th, 2008 · Comments Off on links for November 9th

Comments Off on links for November 9thCategories: links
Tags:

links for November 4th

November 4th, 2008 · Comments Off on links for November 4th

  • Fandom feels like a highly inappropriate way to relate to political life: In my book I discuss the troubling tone of a lot of cultural-taste conversation, the way that it's used to sharpen social distinctions, but at least there the stakes are relatively low (at least in the short term); in politics the consequences feel more dire.

Comments Off on links for November 4thCategories: links
Tags:

links for November 2nd

November 3rd, 2008 · Comments Off on links for November 2nd

Comments Off on links for November 2ndCategories: links
Tags:

links for October 23rd

October 23rd, 2008 · Comments Off on links for October 23rd

Comments Off on links for October 23rdCategories: links
Tags: